But nope, I'm sitting here dissecting the next chapter of Revealing Eden, a book so stupid and offensive that, to quote Linkara of Atop the Fourth Wall, "I would set this [book] on fire right now if I wasn't afraid that I would breathe in the fumes and grow dumber as a result." Yet I persevere because I know that somewhere out there, at least a handful of souls are amused by my suffering.
My face through much of this book
Don't say I don't love you guys...
We now return to Eden and Bramford lying in each other's arms in the middle of the jungle, Bramford tripping out of his mind on extract of magic vine and Eden currently on the "u so hawt luv me" side of her bad case of Borderline Personality Disorder (thank you, Chimera, for the insight). And this chapter opens with a making-out scene complete with moans. I swear this book started out as furry erotica before Foyt decided to turn it into a dystopian novel with a MESSAGE.
Eden softly moaned as Bramford nuzzled her neck. His bare chest grew hot to the touch, his breathing heavy. His lips found hers, teasingly at first. Then he pressed harder, kissing her with hungry passion. She wanted this kiss to last forever.
She caught her breath as he whispered. "My mate." -- p. 218
Hey, if I have to suffer through this, you guys do too...
There's some lovey-dovey talk between the two of them, which Eden takes at face value despite Bramford being stoned out of his mind right now. I don't hang out with stoned people, but I'm gonna guess that you shouldn't expect 100% accuracy out of the mouth of someone high as a kite.
Then comes the whammy.
"Nothing can separate us now."
Nothing. Not ever. That was what Eden believed. Until his next words knocked the wind right out of her.
"Thank you for coming back, Rebecca." -- p. 218-219
Welp... so all that lovey-dovey talk last chapter was actually meant for Rebecca, Eden's oh-so-convenient lookalike. This is why you don't take the words of intoxicated people at face value.
Naturally, this doesn't sit well with Eden, because a world that doesn't revolve around her is just unfair and offensive, you know. She demands to know who Bramford thinks she is, and he repeats "Rebecca." And a little more digging proves that he funded Dr. Newman's research to save Rebecca from the heat, and that all this time it was Rebecca he loved and was trying to save.
Hoo boy, this is gonna be good...
Break out the popcorn, Michael...
A birdlike shriek flew out of her. His love wasn't meant for her, but the girl she resembled. She struggled to get away but he clung to her.
"Rebecca, what's wrong?"
Eden flailed against his chest. "Let me go!"
"I thought you understood."
She bit his shoulder drawing blood. Confusion rushed over Bramford, as he stared at the spot. He slumped to the ground, his head weaving like a drunkard's. -- p. 219
Yay, our oh-so-mature-and-intelligent protagonist is throwing a hissy fit because she got mistaken for someone else. Despite the fact that you KNEW all along that you looked a heck of a lot like this Rebecca chick, that you strongly suspected that Bramford had relations with her at some point, and you were flat-out TOLD that the drug was going to make Bramford loony and say things? What, does your superior intellect only work when you need to fire off a Latin name?
Eden realizes that Bramford must have resented her all along for looking like Rebecca, and knows he'll never see the Real Eden, only Rebecca. "Real Eden" is one of those phrases that just needs to be shot and put out of its misery, along with "Pearl," "Coal," "Midnight Luster," "Aunt Emily," and "hawt jaguar furry." Thank Primus this book never got a legitimate fandom so we don't get these terms plastered all over Tumblr or DeviantArt, I guess...
And of course, because Eden's pissed off she has to lash out at the poor injured drugged-up catman.
Well, if the herbs could test her, she also could test Bramford. She would capitalize on his confusion to discover the truth about Rebecca. Then, like a scorpion, she would sting him with it. She would balance out this cruel equation, his suffering for hers. -- p. 220
Ex-CUSE me, girl? This man has suffered a heck of a lot more than you have over the past week or so. He's lost everything important to him, gotten turned into a jaguar furry against his will, been injured saving YOUR butt from a predator, and now has toxic drugs in his system. You're not "balancing out" any equation, you're just being a spoiled brat who's happy to ignore all Bramford's suffering just to make yourself feel better for getting dumped.
Argh... our heroine, ladies and gentlemen...
So Eden decides to pretend to be Rebecca, and softly asks Bramford what happened. Well, it turns out Rebecca had been hired by the FFP to seduce Bramford into becoming her mate, so she could then turn information about his research over to them. Mkay, that explains a lot...
Actually, it just raises more questions. Why would the FFP, an organization specifically dedicated to wiping out white people, recruit a Pearl to their cause? Why would they target a black man? Why would a Pearl be working for the race-flipped equivalent of the KKK anyhow? And why use a Pearl in the first place instead of a Coal or any of the other races? Did Foyt think any of this through before sticking it in the book?
Okay, I admit, there could be some answers if you analyzed these questions enough -- the FFP might recruit a Pearl to their cause only to eliminate them later, a Pearl might work for anyone if they paid her enough or if she hated her own race, etc. But at the moment, they just give me a headache, and feel like a last-minute addition to throw some more conflict into the story. And I really need to stop analyzing this book and trying to hack a decent, coherent plot out of it.
Stop it, Kenya...
Though now that I think about it, if I absolutely had to read a dystopian novel about a future where the dominant race was black people, I would much rather read about Rebecca's story than Eden's. At least Rebecca sounds like a competent character...
Bramford asks if Rebecca ever really cared for him, and Eden decided to toy with him -- "First, his secrets, then make him suffer." And we're REALLY supposed to be sympathizing with this psychopath?
Eden/Rebecca tells Bramford that she's sorry, but the FFP tricked her and she couldn't believe he really wanted her. We get an odd sidetrack from the story where a bird calls and Eden has to stop and spout off the Latin name (I AM SO SMART, I AM SO SMART, S-M-R-T -- I MEAN S-M-A-R-T), then Bramford replies.
"You're lying," Bramford finally said, the accusation cool and quiet. "You lied to me from the start. They chose you for the job. You only pretended to care...
"I guess I always knew I couldn't trust you," he went on. "Thank Earth, I protected Shen. Only a promise to my wise father stopped me from answering your persistent questions. If the FFP knew Shen was my half-brother, they would have used him against me, too." -- p. 221
Wait, what? Shen and Bramford are half-brothers? Boy, does that slashy moment between them much earlier in the book feel awkward and uncomfortable now... But Foyt insisted earlier that huge divides existed between the races, so why would a black man have a half-Asian brother? Oh wait, this is Foyt, she can't be bothered to maintain continuity in her writing...
Oh, and apparently Bramford and Rebecca have a kid. Wat.
"When our son was born, the truth was plain to see. But how could I let him pay for our crimes?"
Eden's head spun. "You -- I mean -- we have a child?"
"You'd like to forget about him, wouldn't you, Rebecca? I'm sorry to say I once felt the same way." He pummeled the ground. "But what were the odds?"
"Odds of what?"
"Having a child with someone like you. Our son, Logan. A terrible mistake." -- p. 222
Because as long as we're throwing out sudden revelations, let's chuck in a long-lost kid as well. Yeesh... None of this was foreshadowed in the rest of the book -- heck, Shen hasn't been mentioned in so long I'm sure most of you forgot about him until just now -- so having it all pop up here feels like a slap in the face. Foyt, shocking swerves like this don't work unless you set them up in the story. You can't just cram in a "oh by the way, these two random characters are related" without giving the audience some hint or having it fit the logic of the story.
"You were very clever, Rebecca. You begged me to go back home, swore you needed to see your dying father. Even then, you had planned your escape. If I had given you our position here, you would have let them destroy us and never shed a tear."
In a flash, Bramford pinned her down. "Admit it!"
"I, uh..."
"No more lies!"
Eden trembled underneath him. He just might kill her, thinking she was his traitorous mate. -- p. 222
Whoo, Eden's dead, book over!
Eh, we can't be so lucky. Bramford yells in her face, bites her neck, and makes "tortured, groaning sounds." Yeah, I'm thinking this book was a furry porno novel before being reworked into this train wreck.
Eden shouts out "Mr. Bramford, sir!" and that seems to snap him out of it. She asks what happened to Logan, and Bramford says that the FFP demanded their son in exchange for Rebecca, and they killed Rebecca when he refused to hand Logan over. He also says "because of my lies, you and Logan suffered," but we don't find out what lies those are because he picks that moment to fall down and writhe around like a snake, babbling more "shamanistic" nonsense.
What a pair of lonely, unloved freaks. Neither one of them belonged anywhere on this hopeless planet. -- p. 224
While Bramford writhes around, still suffering from the effects of the drug, Eden goes to tend the fire. Yeah, you fail at being a good nurse, girl... She also contemplates ripping the dress into pieces, but thankfully doesn't because I don't want to see Foyt try to describe a naked body of either gender.
Damn Bramford for picking the lock on her heart. Damn the hunger his kiss had awoken in her. And damn that conniving, selfish bitch, Rebecca.
Love? If it did exist, it hurt like Bleeding Earth. -- p. 224
Aaaaaaaaand end chapter. Notice that almost every female character in this book that isn't Eden is a bitch according to Eden? Lovely...
So all the lovey-dovey crap in the previous chapter is a cop-out, Bramford's still stoned out of his gourd, Eden's a heartless brat (but we all knew that), and this revelation about Rebecca's identity just raises even more questions. Are we having FUN with this book yet?
Someone should have taught Foyt what "Chekov's Gun" is. And since, to the surprise of no one, this book is still train-wreck, I'll move over to Hobb's "Liveship Traders" series and say it's a super good read. I should go find the next books in the... series of series... serieses? serii? except I already have enough unread books in my collection.
ReplyDeleteIt sounds as if Foyt needed to attend a writing workshop before churning this out. Her book might have still been offensive as all get out, but at least the writing might have been decent, or at least merely mediocre.
DeleteI wasn't too thrilled with the first book of the "Rain Wild" series, which is apparently a sequel series to the "Liveship Traders," but the first 3% of "Ship of Magic" has been good enough that I'm willing to give it a further shot. Good to hear it's worth sticking with.
One of the character I started out loathing because wow, whiny self-centred brat much? But by the end of the trilogy I was all: "You go girl, kick all the ass, you are the best," because UNLIKE SOMEONE (*cough*Eden*cough*) everybody in Hobb's books actually gets character development.
DeleteThe kid's name is "Logan"? So their child is Wolverine???
ReplyDeleteThat explains everything! This whole world came about because of X-Men mutation! XD
I didn't even draw that connection until you pointed it out. XD No wonder Wolverine has issues, his father's a cat-man. XD
DeleteI tried to comment a couple days ago but I think the website ate it. Main question:
ReplyDeleteBramford's research has always been about curing/preventing The Heat, right? The research that the FPP wanted. The research that Bramford began to save Rebecca was the same research that the FPP hired Rebecca to get information about.
Am I confused, or are we trapped in a recursive "Bramford met Rebecca because the FPP wanted the research that Bramford was doing with the intention of saving Rebecca"?
Or was he doing some other research before hiring Dr Newman?
Also I love that the plan, after the Rebecca plan didn't work, was "get Jamal to seduce information about the research from Eden." You'd think there would be other, better plans than "seduce the information out of people close to the project."
Yeah, I never got notification of your comment, so I'm guessing either Blogger ate it or it got sent to my spam folder and I deleted it by accident. (I have comment moderation on to avoid spambots and the like.) Sorry about that.
DeleteYeesh, that IS a stable loop. I suppose Bramford could have been doing other research or have other resources the FFP wants (I don't think it was ever specified what sort of business Bramford owns), but the book never mentioned them.
Well, of COURSE that has to be their main plan! Otherwise we couldn't have our tragic "beauty and the beast" romance that people love so much- *gags and chokes* Sorry, can't type that with a straight face...
I kept thinking "surely I read this wrong, surely we don't have the gaping plot whole of a stable time loop from this new revelation" but I guess we do. Fantastic.
DeleteI really hope that they already had the third version of the plan in the works, to seduce Dr Newman. Like obviously that had to be the next step, right?